Empty executive chair at the head of a boardroom table in early morning light

The Approval Trap: Why Leaders Who Need to Be Liked Stop Leading

By Dr. William R. Latchford, DCJ

One of the most dangerous addictions in leadership is approval.

Not the obvious kind, where a leader needs everyone to like them and everybody in the building can see it. That version is easy to spot and easy to dismiss. The dangerous version is subtle. It looks like wisdom. It sounds like collaboration. It feels, from the inside, like being a good listener. And it quietly hollows out a leader’s ability to do the job.

How it starts

Nobody sets out to lead by consensus-seeking. It begins with reasonable instincts: wanting the team on board, wanting to avoid unnecessary conflict, wanting the board or the council to feel heard. Those are good instincts. The problem starts when approval stops being one input and becomes the compass.

The moment that happens, clarity disappears. The leader is no longer asking “What is right?” They are asking “What will they accept?” Those are different questions, and over time they produce very different organizations.

What it looks like in practice

Hard truths get softened until they no longer land. A performance problem becomes “an opportunity for growth.” A budget shortfall becomes “something we’re monitoring.” The words are chosen for how they will be received, not for whether they are accurate.

Necessary decisions get delayed. The restructuring everyone knows is coming sits on the desk for another quarter because a respected colleague disagrees with it. The policy change waits for one more round of input. The delay is framed as diligence. It is usually avoidance.

Explanations multiply. A leader who is anchored says what they decided and why, once. A leader who is managing approval explains, re-explains, and over-explains, hoping the right combination of words will make the disagreement go away. It never does.

In thirty-two years of public safety leadership, I watched this pattern take capable people apart. They were not weak. They were not incompetent. They had simply let the approval of others become the thing they were protecting, and once that happens, everything else becomes negotiable.

Anchored is not the same as rigid

I want to be careful here, because the opposite error is just as real. Strong leadership is not rigidity. It is not the chief who never listens, the executive director who has already decided before the meeting starts, the board chair who mistakes stubbornness for principle.

The distinction is what you are anchored to. A rigid leader is anchored to their ego, and they bend for nobody because bending feels like losing. An anchored leader is fixed on principles and mission, and they listen carefully, change their mind when the argument is better, and still hold the line when it isn’t. You can be fully open to input and still refuse to let the vote decide what is right.

The tension test

Here is the practical version of all this. There will be moments when you are misunderstood. When a decision costs you popularity with people whose opinion you value. When silence is stronger than defense and you have to let a criticism stand unanswered because answering would only feed it.

If you cannot tolerate that tension, you cannot lead at a high level. It is that simple.

Leaders who can’t tolerate tension end up managing perception instead of managing reality. And the organization can feel the difference. Teams know when their leader is deciding based on what is true and when they are deciding based on who is in the room.

The tension of restructuring when people you respect disagree. The tension of holding a boundary when your board pushes back. The tension of telling a long-serving employee that the standard has changed and they have to meet it. These are not failures of leadership. They are the job.

Conviction over applause

The leaders who create long-term stability, in a tribal government, a police department, a housing authority, or a corporation, are not driven by applause. They are driven by conviction. They have decided what the organization is for, and they measure decisions against that instead of against the room.

That does not make them popular in every moment. It makes them trusted over time, which is a different and far more durable thing.

Leadership is not about being agreed with. It is about being steady when you aren’t.


Dr. William R. Latchford, DCJ, is President of Native Peacekeeper Consulting Group and the retired Chief of Police and Executive Director of Public Safety for the Seminole Tribe of Florida. NPKCG delivers executive leadership training for Tribal governments and organizations. Learn about our leadership programs →